To be honest I’m not sure what I would do if buying today. If you go for a 190 Elegance or R-Line you will be paying luxury tax, it is unavoidable now. So they definitely fall into the ‘in for a penny, in for a pound’ category. So I guess I would be looking at what else I could get over £40k or compromising my engine choice and dropping down to a 150.
The Tiguan R is still almost £10k more than the R-Line for standard builds but depends on what options you would need to put on the R-Line.
When I was looking 190 Elegance I figured that the R was almost £12k more because I was confident (at the time) that my choice would not be subject to luxury tax. So at the time there is no way I would have gone for the R. What would I do now, hard to say, the R is still a lot extra.
Personally, I think if I could role back time I would have gone with the same spec but with the 150 TSI rather than the 190 TSI. In fact, if VW approached me today and said “look, the 190 drivetrain is a problem, you can stick with it but you won’t get your car until 2023 but you could change to a 150PS and have it in August” I would be sorely tempted.
Cheers,
Nigel